Test-driving Intel® Xeon Phi™ coprocessors with a basic N-body simulation

Intel® Xeon Phi™ coprocessors are capable of delivering more performance and better energy efficiency than Intel® Xeon® processors for certain parallel applications. In this paper, we investigate the porting and optimization of a test problem for the Intel Xeon Phi coprocessor. The test problem is a basic N-body simulation, which is the foundation of a number of applications in computational astrophysics and biophysics. Using common code in the C language for the host processor and for the coprocessor, we benchmark the N-body simulation. The simulation runs 2.3x to 5.4x times faster on a single Intel Xeon Phi coprocessor than on two Intel Xeon E5 series processors. The performance depends on the accuracy settings for transcendental arithmetics. We also study the assembly code produced by the compiler from the C code. This allows us to pinpoint some strategies for designing C/C++ programs that result in efficient automatically vectorized applications for Intel Xeon family devices.

The visualization shown below demonstrates the results and the performance of the N-body simulation on Intel Xeon processors and Intel Xeon Phi coprocessors. The code running the visualization has the same force calculation algorithm as the code presented in the paper.

CORRECTION

Thanks to Georg Hager for pointing out the missing compiler argument -xAVX for the host version of the code! The corrected result is reported in the addendum. The performance with -xhost (equivalent to -xAVX on our system) is shown in the last set of bars in the plot below (click to enlarge).

Paper with addendum (correction):  Colfax_Nbody_Xeon_Phi-with-addendum.pdf (2 MB) — this file is available only to registered users. Register or Log In.